SEO Weekly

Some clicks in your Google report may be fake

One SEO says the odd numbers started at the end of October and follow the same pattern across sites.

Fake click data is showing up in Google Search Console, according to SEO Joy Hawkins. Search Console is the free Google tool that tells you which searches your site showed up for and how many people clicked. Hawkins says the bad numbers have been appearing since the end of October.

The problem is that it does not look wrong at first glance. Your overall click total looks normal enough. It only falls apart when you go keyword by keyword or page by page.

What the fake data looks like

Hawkins says she is seeing "insane CTRs on keywords that you're not close to being in the top positions for." CTR means click-through rate, the share of people who saw your listing in search and clicked it. A high rate on a keyword where you rank near the top of page one makes sense. A high rate on a keyword where you sit far down the results does not, because almost nobody scrolls that far.

She also says the affected sites all show the same patterns, which is what makes her think the data itself is wrong rather than something unusual happening with real searchers.

Who this affects

Anyone who uses Search Console to judge how their pages are doing. If you have been looking at a keyword report from the last few weeks and feeling good about a sudden jump, that jump may not be real. The same goes the other way if you were about to make a decision, like rewriting a page title or dropping a keyword, based on numbers from this window.

This is one SEO reporting it. Google has not said anything about it in the source here, so there is no fix and no official timeline.

What to do

Open Search Console, click Performance, then switch to the Queries tab and sort by clicks. Look at the position column next to the top clicked keywords. If a keyword is showing a pile of clicks while sitting at position 20 or 40, treat that row as suspect rather than as a win.

Then leave your site alone for now. Do not rewrite pages, change titles or shift your plan based on data from the end of October onward until this clears up. Compare against another source you trust instead, like your own analytics tool or your actual sales and enquiries, which are harder to fake and are the numbers that pay you anyway.

If your Search Console numbers have looked strange lately, you are probably not imagining it.

Joy Hawkins
@JoyanneHawkins
X
So don't trust your GSC data - this has been happening since the end of October.
Nov 17, 2026 · View on X

Be the person who already knew

One email a day. Under three minutes. You will hear about a Google change before it shows up in your traffic.

Get the next one by email

A daily read of what the sharpest SEOs on X actually said. What changed in search, whether it touches your site, what to do. Every quote links out.